Quirky colleges in the Northeast?

Hi all, My daughter (GPA 3.35 overall, but a 3.6 junior year post attention medication) is looking for a college that is somewhat quirky with less of an emphasis on sports. She's into art, manga, cosplay, science fiction, movies and books and is looking at liberal arts colleges because she might want to major in English, literature or history. She really liked Clark in Worcester because of the off beat kids and the funky vibe, plus the interesting clubs and activities and the majors. But, a safer area would be better, plus I don't think she'll get any merit aid there which will put it out of reach financially. She also loved Assumption for its peaceful feel and the academics. She's worried that she won't fit in there, however. Does anyone have any other suggestions for schools to look at? Thanks!